Inconvenient memories: Veteran’s Day 2014

by Guest Author Ross Caputi

cost ofwar
Iraq war protest poster showing Lancet estimate of Iraqis killed, May 28, 2008. Licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution 2.0 Generic license. Author: Random McRandomhead.

Most Americans believe Veterans Day is a day of remembrance; in reality, it’s generally a day of forgetting.

On Veterans Day, people applaud as veterans march in parades, wearing their medals and fancy uniforms. People who have never seen or smelt war’s rotting corpses bask in an atmosphere of pride and patriotism, suppressing inconvenient memories of hundreds of thousands of civilians killed in Iraq, millions in Vietnam, hundreds of thousands in Korea, and so on throughout our nation’s short and bloody history.

On Veterans Day, we are spared all the unpleasantries that might give us pause about the value or benevolence of our wars. We listen to the bands playing, but ignore the troubles faced by returning veterans. Where is the glory in PTSD, addiction, suicide?

On Veterans Day, we make believe that support for the troops is apolitical. Just like the victims of our wars, the reasons why young Americans have been asked to go to war, and the consequences of those wars are conveniently forgotten and nobody seems to notice.

On Veterans Day, we are called upon to remember America’s wars, sanitized of the harm they brought to countless victims around the world, and abstracted from their historical and political context. We are asked to support our veterans while forgetting the reality of what they participated in. It is a pleasant fairy tale, and I wish I could partake in it. But my experience as a Marine in Iraq has forever changed the way I look at war and the way I feel about being a veteran.

Let’s change the way we celebrate Veterans Day. Let’s make it a day of learning, not forgetting. Let’s be sympathetic to the ways veterans have suffered without ignoring the suffering of civilian victims. Let’s teach and learn about the wars in which our veterans have participated without glossing over the historical and political context in which they occurred. Let’s end the reflexive support for popular mythology, the jingoism, the cheer-leading, and the forgetting. Let’s refuse to encourage the next generation to follow in the footsteps of today’s veterans.

Can we get there from here? Pursuing nonviolence

Trination Mega Festival : Bangladesh India Pakistan Photographs by Faisal Akram Licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 2.0 Generic license.

Discouraging stories, infuriating stories, heart-breaking stories abound.

The media shout out their tales and pummel us with their gory photos, of violence, murder, rape, hatred, and we at Engaging Peace try to provide some different perspectives, regarding events…

In Gaza

In the Ukraine

In Nigeria

In Central America

And in Ferguson Missouri

Engaging Peace has had posts on most of these horrifying stories, but, stubbornly, we have also continued to press the feasibility of nonviolence, most recently with posts from Dr. Ian Hansen and Dr. Majed Ashy as well as reminders from Ross Caputi and Dr. Alice LoCicero of ways in which you can help.

In today’s short post, I invite you to learn more about an important peace initiative aimed at promoting a stable peace between India and Pakistan.

Please be inspired by this model and send your words and images on behalf of peace and social justice—starting perhaps with the work that needs to be done in your own country.

Anyone anywhere can work for peace and nonviolence. The world will be better off if you join the endeavor.

 

No more Veterans Days

By guest author Ross Caputi

What is the point of Veterans Day?

Veterans support Occupy movement
Veterans support Occupy movement. Photo by Slowking4 used under CC Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 Unported license.

I have a proposal. The only sensible goal that Veterans Day could ever have is not to have any more Veterans Days. Veterans Day must become self-defeating.

That this proposal seems shocking to some is evidence that war and the “heroic veteran” have become permanent parts of our culture. They have become traditions in our society.

My proposal will seem shocking to some because we live in a warrior society, where special rights and esteem are given to our warriors, but not to our civilians.

In our society, war is a tradition that veterans have carried on each generation. Civilians no longer look to the day when we no longer have wars, and as a consequence no longer have veterans. This is unimaginable.

The current purpose of Veterans Day is to celebrate this tradition and indoctrinate the next generation, who look up to our society’s warriors and will follow in their footsteps.

This must stop. For veterans to continue to enjoy their special status in our society is self-serving and short sighted. We veterans have a moral responsibility to renounce these traditions.

Veterans Day must become a day when veterans share their experience with civilians, not in search of praise, but to educate about the horrors and injustice of war.

Veterans must ensure that the next generation does not follow in their footsteps.

Ross Caputi

The special status of veterans

By guest author Ross Caputi

Veterans enjoy a special status in American culture. By cultural definition alone, they are regarded as heroes. And on Veterans Day we celebrate these heroes without question.

Vietnam Veterans Memorial
Vietnam Veterans Memorial. Photo by Kkmd used under CC Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 Unported license.

But is this tradition of Veterans Day sensible? Were the wars that our veterans fought truly heroic? Did they “serve” anyone besides the 1%?

Consider my own experience as a veteran of the occupation of Iraq, for example.

Did I defend America? No. There is now ample evidence that Bush lied to America to justify invading Iraq, which was never a threat to us.

Did I help Iraqis? No. I helped destroy the city of Fallujah during Operation Phantom Fury in 2004, in which we killed several thousand civilians, forced 200,000 people to become refugees, and caused a major health crisis.

Was my time in the military a “service” to anyone? Yes. I drove convoys to help government-contracted construction companies make a fortune in Iraq. I helped non-Iraqi oil companies gain access to Iraq’s resources. I tested new weapons in combat situations for weapon manufacturers, which led to large government contracts (paid for with taxpayer dollars), large profits for the weapons manufacturers, and a lot of death and destruction for Iraqis. I “served” the 1%.

Do I deserve free college or free health care because of what I did while I was in the military? No more than any other human being deserves free education and free health care as a right. I certainly did not earn the right to education and health care by participating in an illegal and immoral occupation.

Ross Caputi